Moving from 'Learning' to solving a 'Real Business Issue'
Focus on solving a business issue
Learning returns the highest benefit when it is properly applied to solving real business problems. We recommend the line manager and the employee agree on measurable goals that will address known business issues.
The employee might then need to attend a development program such as this workshop. The objective is not just to attend a workshop, but rather to increase the employee’s business and financial acumen, and as a direct result of this development program, identify and help achieve specific, measurable, value-creating performance goals. To illustrate moving from learning-related goals to performance-related goals, we have prepared the following suggestions, which of course should be modified to meet the specific needs of the line manager and employee.
A business issue is on the table
Manager asks employee to solve the business issue
Training takes place with the issue in mind
Employee focuses on solving the issue
Employee reports outcome
Issue needs to be solved asap
Employee is unclear how to do that
Definition of KPIs to solve the issue
Training will be recommended to help solve the issue
Maybe a workshop
Maybe on-line
Employee addresses the issue with the newly acquainted knowledge
Employee shares how it was possible to meet the KPIs
Issue is solved
Value creating performance
Value-Creating Goal
Based on insights from this workshop, participants should be able to identify relevant financial reporting risks (USGAAP/EVM) and recommend ways to manage them.
Suggested application tasks in order to meet the above-mentioned goal
Consult the process documentation in your area
Consult the Risk and Controls Self Assessment (RCSA) in your area
Identify potential reporting risks / control gaps
Suggest mitigating actions (self raised issues, control improvements)
Consult ORM and/or Finance Governance to implement mitigating actions
Summary
Addressing business issues - in a context of learning - promises to produce impressive ROIs.
When we consider all the benefits and costs, this type of training/development investment creates significant value and provides impressive quantifiable returns, both for the employee and for Swiss Re. Therefore, this approach moves us far beyond "just learning something"; it focuses us on the positive business outcomes by quantifying the expected costs and resulting value creation.
Our Thoughts – the Return on Investment (ROI) Calculation
This activity promises a strong ROI of 255%
The sections below reveal our calculation.
Select each thought (+) to learn more about it.
Quantifiable value: Assume as a result of this workshop, each participant identifies and cures two risk mitigation deficiencies where risk can be properly managed and mitigated instead of a control failure that would occur.
Assume remediation of the reportable control failure (versus non-reportable) requires 12 total hours work for the control owner and the line manager. Assuming 1 of the 2 identified control failures is reportable, the total time savings resulting from avoiding the reportable control failure would be US$2,040 (12 hours at an average cost of US$170 per hour).
Further assume remediation of the non-reportable control failure (versus reportable) requires 3 total hours of work for the control owner and the line manager. Assuming 1 of the 2 identified reporting errors is non-reportable, the total time savings would be US$1,020 (6 hours at an average cost of US$170 per hour). Combining the above yearly savings for each participant produces an annual savings of US$3,060 (US$2,040 + US$1,020).
Non-quantifiable value: Besides these measurable values, there are also non-quantitative benefits of this workshop. These include for example reduced auditing exposure and better governance, as well as the enhancement of work quality, all of which materializes over time. Although not included in the ROI calculation below, the other important, and often neglected impact, is that of reputational damage, caused for instance from material misstatements of the financials which could exceed US$10 million. The assumed value per avoided item is 0.1%, therefore the imputed value each avoided item could be in excess of US$10,000 (US$10 million x 0.1%).
Assume the cost of participating in the 1.5-hour training is US$150 based on ¼ of the Swiss Re average cost of a workshop day.
Also assume the opportunity cost for being away from the desk for 1.5 hours is US$350 (US$1,400 * 25%). We can assume that half a day of work is required to apply the findings and to achieve the above-mentioned performance goals, which adds US$700 opportunity cost for not being productive.
Therefore, the total related cost of this learning investment is assumed to be US$1,200 (US$150 + US$350 + US$700).
The ROI in this case equates to a high 255% (US$3,060/US$1,200).
Don’t forget this ROI calculation is not considering the above-mentioned non-quantifiable value.
Additional savings could result since the savings could reoccur in subsequent years and the learnings from the workshop could be applied to other situations. In your own individual case, the numbers may differ, our intention here is to offer an example for creating your own ROI calculations.
Agree on your goal
Structured learning
Social learning
On-the-job learning
Select each light blue number to discover more.
Talk with your manager - Agree on an outcome based goal.
Prepare online.
Who is this for?
Everyone in the company who is exposed to deal with financially relevant information in any way. Open to all bands.
Competency level:
Completing the training options will raise the competency level to "basic". Completing the "20%" and "70%" actions will raise the competency level from "basic" to approaching "proficient".
We suggest using the text below for your development goal:
"To be regarded as a person in your area who is able to identify and react appropriately to any risk related to financial reporting accuracy"
Avoid: Attend workshop xyz
What are the requirements?
None
Class based. Get the basics quickly.
Workshop: "Financial Reporting Risk Training"
Duration: 2 hours
Description: This session will introduce the general concepts to mitigate financial reporting risk. Participants will get an overview on annual ICoFR activities that includes roles and responsibilities as well as tools used.
Key topics covered:
Internal Controls over Financial Reporting (ICoFR) – Background information
ICoFR annual cycle; tasks, roles and responsibilities
Swiss Re Control Framework and the principle of 3 lines of defense
Overview of Swiss Re’s Risk catalogue
Control maintenance process
Issue and Operational Events handling
End User Applications (EUA) identification and classification
Identify a peer and discuss how he/she handles financial reporting risk in his/her area
Identify similarities and differences in how financial reporting risk is mitigated and discuss this with a knowledgeable peer
Schedule a lunch or coffee with a local expert from Finance Governance to deepen your understanding in this area. Don’t be shy to ask all questions which you might have at this time
Based on insights from this workshop, participants should be able to identify relevant financial reporting risks (USGAAP/EVM) and recommend ways to manage them.
Suggested tasks in order to meet the above-mentioned goal
Consult the process documentation in your area
Consult the Risk and Controls Self Assessment (RCSA) in your area
Identify potential reporting risks / control gaps
Suggest mitigating actions (self raised issues, control improvements)
Consult ORM and/or Finance Governance to implement mitigating actions